More than 20 years ago, I was involved with two Disney fan movements that, by any reasonable measure, failed.
One was Save Disney Animation, a sister organization to Save Disney Shows that was also aligned with Preserve the Magic. We were fighting to save traditional 2D animation at Disney.
The other was Save Our Stitch.
And despite the name, we weren’t trying to save Stitch.
We knew Stitch was fine.
We were trying to save his ’ohana.
Now Disney Animation is bringing us Lilo & Scratch, a new animated short opening with Hexed on November 25. It’s the first theatrical short from Walt Disney Animation Studios in five years, and Disney developed a new animation pipeline for it combining hand-drawn and CG animation while trying to remain faithful to the look of the original Lilo & Stitch.
And suddenly, two supposedly lost causes don’t look quite as lost as they did before.
Save Disney Animation
There was a time when it appeared Disney was finished with traditional animation.
Home on the Range was, at the time, supposed to be the end of Disney’s traditionally animated features. Save Disney Animation was one of the groups fighting against that direction.
And for a while, it looked like maybe we won.
Disney eventually brought traditional animation back. The Princess and the Frog arrived in 2009 and was mildly successful.
Then came Frozen.
Disney’s CG films became enormous hits, traditional animation disappeared from the feature slate again, and this time it stayed gone.
So we lost.
Or did we?
Lilo & Scratch is not Disney suddenly bringing traditional animation back. Disney says the short combines hand-drawn and CG animation through an entirely new pipeline developed specifically for the project.
But what the filmmakers have accomplished is fascinating.
At Annecy, they showed backgrounds from the new short made both traditionally and digitally, with the differences reportedly almost impossible to spot. They also showed a shot recreating the appearance of the original movie. Lilo and Stitch looked traditionally animated until the shot rotated and revealed that they were actually 3D models. Another demonstration put a 3D Stitch and a 2D Scratch together seamlessly in the same scene.
I’ll admit, my first reaction wasn’t entirely positive.
I’m something of a purist. Making a 3D model look like traditional animation isn’t the same thing as traditional animation. After spending part of the early 2000s arguing that Disney shouldn’t abandon the art form, this wasn’t exactly the victory I had in mind.
Then I showed it to my partner, Jackie.
I thought she would be upset that Disney was, in a sense, “faking” the traditional look with modern tools.
Instead, she was happy they had found a way to make it work.
The final result looks good. That’s what mattered to her.
I hadn’t really considered it that way.
But maybe the objective was bigger than the technique.
Was Save Disney Animation about preserving one particular method of making animation?
Or was it about preserving an artistic tradition, a style and a feeling that we believed Disney was abandoning?
I don’t know.
Maybe it was. Maybe it wasn’t.
Maybe the answer will be different depending on the person.
But Lilo & Scratch makes the question worth asking again.
And Then There’s Scratch
This brings us back to that other supposedly failed movement.
Lilo & Stitch: The Series was built around a fantastic concept. The other 625 experiments had been dehydrated and dropped across Hawaii. With a few exceptions, each episode was about a different experiment activating, causing some mayhem, and eventually being helped by Lilo, who found its “one true place.”
There was an obvious problem from the start.
There were 625 experiments.
They were going to need a lot more than 65 episodes.
They didn’t get them.
That was what Save Our Stitch was actually about.
We weren’t worried about Experiment 626. Stitch was the star. Stitch wasn’t going anywhere.
We wanted to save his ’ohana.
By and large, Disney didn’t continue that story. Instead, Stitch went on to become one of Disney’s most popular characters. Disney itself now points to his enormous presence across clothing, collectibles, games, toys and other merchandise.

His extended family hasn’t received anywhere near that attention.
Experiment 624, Angel, is obviously the big exception. Experiment 625, Reuben, and 629, Leroy, have occasionally resurfaced. But by and large, Disney has ignored the other experiments while Stitch became a phenomenon in his own right.
And now we have Scratch.
Disney calls Scratch a mysterious new alien who becomes part of Lilo’s ’ohana.
That sounds awfully familiar to anyone who has watched Lilo & Stitch: The Series.
While we don’t know for sure that she’s one of Jumba’s missing experiments, it almost doesn’t matter. The end result is the same.
Lilo has encountered another strange alien creature, discovered there’s more to her than first meets the eye, and brought her into the family.
That’s the story Save Our Stitch wanted Disney to keep telling.
At least, that’s my argument.
Jackie strongly disagrees.
To her, it matters very much whether Scratch is actually one of Jumba’s experiments. A new alien joining Lilo’s ’ohana might capture the spirit of the old series, but that’s not the same thing as finally returning to the hundreds of experiments the series left behind.
And once again, she made me look at the question differently.
Because this is essentially the same question we were just asking about the animation.
Maybe the Objective Was Bigger Than the Technique
Interestingly, Jackie and I come down on opposite sides of the two questions.
She’s perfectly happy with the new animation technique if the final result works. I’m a little more of a purist.
When it comes to Scratch, I’m the one willing to say the distinction almost doesn’t matter. Jackie isn’t. To her, if Scratch isn’t one of Jumba’s experiments, it isn’t the same thing.
And I don’t think either of us is necessarily wrong.
More than 20 years ago, Save Disney Animation wanted Disney to preserve traditional animation. Save Our Stitch wanted Disney to keep exploring Stitch’s larger ’ohana.
We didn’t get either of those things.
Not really.
But now Lilo & Scratch looks and feels like the animation we fought to preserve while telling the kind of story we wanted Disney to keep telling.
Maybe the objective was bigger than the technique.
Neither is the clear win we wanted.
But this is good news all the same.
Sources
- The Walt Disney Company, “Inside the Making of ‘Lilo & Scratch,’ from Returning Talent to a New Animation Pipeline”: https://thewaltdisneycompany.com/news/disney-animation-lilo-and-scratch/
- TheWrap, “New Animated ‘Lilo & Stitch’ Short Attached to Disney’s ‘Hexed’ This Fall”: https://www.thewrap.com/creative-content/movies/lilo-and-stitch-animated-short-lilo-and-scratch-explained/